top of page

NYU Presidential Global Debates

When envisioning the program, NYU President Emeritus John Sexton — a champion debater and debate coach — said, "The key idea of NYU as a global network university is that our students and faculty, regardless of location, are part of one university. While many of our pursuits, both scholarly and extracurricular, will be particular to one campus, as NYU continues to evolve as a global network university, many others will take place across the network." 

 

The NYU Presidential Global Debates tournament competition returned in 2015 with a new home [the Business & society Program within the Stern School of Business] and under new leadership [Will Baker, Director of the Global Debate Fund]. 

 

The intra-school debate competition pits undergraduate debate teams from the entire NYU global network against one another in a contest that will award prizes totaling over $50,000.  In the spring, the top domestic entrants and the top international entrants will form the Sweet 16 and participate in a single-day elimination that will culminate in a final round judged by a VIP Panel that includes key faculty and administrators at NYU. 

 

A new resolution is determined annually and can be found on  the Announcements page of the site or on the Facebook page. 

7aa08ed4d0f6101bea94213841bba700.png
4e988831d6a5590983672bd2624415d9.png

Format For Domestic Competition

There are eight speeches in the debate. The first four are five minutes each, followed by cross-examinations from the other team.

 

  • 1st Aff. Speech (5 minutes) | Cross-ex. By Negative (2 minutes)

  • 1st Neg Speech (5 minutes) | Cross-ex. By Aff (2 minutes)

  • 2nd Aff. Speech (5 minutes) | Cross-ex. By Neg. (2 minutes)

  • 2nd Neg. Speech (5 minutes) | Cross-ex. By Aff. (2 minutes)

  • In these speeches, put out your arguments, supporting data, and, initial responses to the other side.

  • The next four speeches are three minutes long, and called REBUTTALS.

  • 1st Negative Rebuttal (3 minutes) | 1st Affirmative Rebuttal (3 minutes)

  • 2nd Negative Rebuttal (3 minutes) | 2nd Affirmative Rebuttal (3 minutes)

These speeches are the comparison of the merits of the arguments.

Rules

  • Eligibility for Domestic Competition
    To be eligible for competition a student must be a matriculated undergraduate at NYU for the semester of competition. A team for competition is to consist of two undergraduate students from any of the NYU schools in any combination (i.e., students from different schools may compete together on the same competitive team). The organizers will make every effort to assist interested students who are unpaired in finding a partner. Students may participate in the annual NYU Global Debate Program up to four times.
  • Eligibility for International Competition
    To be eligible for competition a student must be a matriculated undergraduate NYU student enrolled at one of NYU's international study sites. A team for competition is to consist of two undergraduate students from any of the NYU schools in any combination. Students are strongly encouraged to find partners attending the same international study site. Students may participate in the annual NYU Global Debate Program up to four times.
  • Domestic Tournament Rules
    All competitors will be entered in a preliminary competition tournament. The tournament will consist of three rounds on the same day. Each round will contain five-minute constructive speeches, three-minute rebuttals, and two-minute cross examination. Each team will have five minutes of preparation time per round. Judges will have an optional five minute cross-examination period. Each student will complete one constructive, one rebuttal, one response to cross examination, and one questioning during cross examination per round. Rounds will be judged by faculty of the University and special guest judges. Within each round judges will assign a winner of the debate to one side only. Judges will also assign each competitor a rank and a score reflective of their speaking. These points will be used to determine ties in ranking of teams. Teams will first be ranked based on number of wins, then on team points, and finally team ranks. The top teams will continue to the Elimination Tournament. The continuing teams will be announced within three days of the close of preliminary competition. Judges will write ballots explaining the basis of their decision. The decision of a judge may not be challenged in a round or changed once entered. The preliminary tournament will be randomly matched for round one & two, and be power-paired for round three. All tournament procedures, alterations, and questions shall be resolved by the Coordinator, who shall function as Tournament Director.
  • International Tournament Rules
    All competitors will submit four-minute videos for the preliminary competition tournament. Videos will present arguments in favor of or against the resolution. Judges will review and score each video submission. Teams will be ranked by points with ties broken on judge preference. The continuing teams will be announced within three days of the close of preliminary competition. Judges will write ballots explaining the basis of their scoring. The decision of a judge may not be challenged or changed once entered. All tournament procedures, alterations, and questions shall be resolved by the Coordinator, who shall function as Tournament Director.
  • Elimination Round Rules
    The tournament will consist of four elimination rounds: octofinals, quarterfinals, semifinals on the same day with a championship round held on a separate day. Speech and cross-examination times will remain the same as for the domestic prelim tournament. Teams will be seeded based on the video submission ballots and the results of the domestic prelim tournament. Each round will have a minimum of three judges. Judges will have a twelve minute cross-examination period. Each student will complete one constructive, and one rebuttal. Cross-examination periods may be shared. Rounds will be judged by faculty, alumni, previous competitors and administrators of the University as well as special guest judges. Within each round judges will assign a winner of the debate to one side only. All tournament procedures, alterations, and questions shall be resolved by the Program Director, who shall function as Tournament Director. The decision of the judges may not be challenged or changed once entered.
  • Competitor Support and Guidelines
    Any student competitor will be free to ask for additional instruction or advice at any time via appointment. The Coordinator will be an impartial resource for all competitors. All competitors will be entitled to the Debate Resource Bibliography. All competitors may ask faculty of the University for advice on issues related to topic and argument. All competitors will be expected to uphold the ethical considerations of academic discourse in the process of competition and to represent the University, their school, and themselves to the best of their ability. A 15 minute forfeit rule will be in place for head-to-head competitions during each phase of the domestic tournament. Teams may work together and practice with other teams prior to competition to maximize preparation. Student awards may be subject to additional terms of disbursement by the University pending legal and tax obligations.
  • Elimination Round Participation and Team Obligations
    If one competitor from a team is unable to participate in the elimination rounds due to verified medical reasons or visa problems, the remaining competitor will be able to secure a different partner for the elimination rounds. If a competitor from a team chooses not to participate for any other reason, the remaining competitor will have the option to debate singly or forfeit their elimination rounds. In any event, no single-member team will be permitted to advance past the semifinal round under any circumstances. The team member who did not compete will receive the octofinal award regardless of how far their partner advances. Each member of all sixteen advancing teams agree to be present for all scheduled events organized by the sponsors including the elimination rounds, any welcome reception, the awards ceremony and the Championship Final Round. Failure to attend these events will lead to forfeiture of their award.
Image by Colton Duke

Preparing leaders through the transformative power of NYU debate!

bottom of page